The sound of a bat meeting a ball…and my Phillies are edging toward last place...then I think of being a softball “ringer” for the 4th Methodist church!
I played in the Church Softball League in Millville every summer that I was in high school. It started right after school let out and ran to late July. And it was a fierce competitive fast pitch game. Of course the Presbyterians assumed they would win every game. But the Methodists tried each year to change and we did most of the time. But there was a catch – one had to go to Sunday for at least a month before the season to qualify for a team. And so each year in May all of the south Millville boys would reluctantly attend Sunday school for the required time. And the pastor, who led the older boy’s class, went along with this because I am sure he secretly wanted to beat the Presby’s and perhaps even the Baptist too.
And so we sang “What a Friend…and Brighten the Corner'' and listened to Bible stories told with flannel board illustrations - but we were thinking of softball and who had this year to play what positions. Another requirement, we all had to buy a bilious lime green and yellow team t-shirt @ $2.95 that was supplied by Jim’s Sport Spot (at cost as his donations) with 4th Methodist emblazoned on the front. I used my old green baseball cap and saved $5.00. Today the kid’s outfits would cost two hundred dollars and be produced by Ralph Lauren (not at cost!).
We certainly lived in a simpler time - where performance on the field trumped your outfit.
We were ringers all in the best/worst sense of the concept. But it gets worse. We all also played simultaneously on a second team in a “slow-pitch” league under a different name, which was against the rules. And sometimes two games the same day. To accomplish this feat we all had other pseudonyms for our box scores in the Millville Daily Republican – our play on the diamond was big news in our sleepy summer town. My name was Nivlac = clever huh? Charles P, the wearer of soda bottle bottom glasses, was Magoo. It worked. We were never caught for this serious violation of sportsmanship ( akin to deflating a football or corking a bat in today’s wide world of sport. To save time, we had one team name printed on the outside and the other on inside out of our shirts - flip 'em and we became Shone’s Body Shop – which made life easier especially when we had to race to the second game after chalking another easy victory. And I must say we were good. The 1960 season was the best we ever played - out record: 10 and 1 and 9 and 0 ( the one loss was a forfeiture when the first game went into extra innings and we never made it to the second game)!
About half way into the season Reverend G. spoke to our captain Brad on the way out of church and reported that our team was invited to play an “exhibition game” against the Inmate All-Stars of the Leesburg State Prison Farm - Farmers. He thought it would be, “Good Fun and a very Christain thing to do” We of course immediately agreed - a game is a game and his game had to be more exciting than the Sunday Scholars contests which we easily won twice a week. These were men who had plenty of time to practice andv of course at the prison because all of their games were home games!
And so we carpooled (which meant half the team squeezed into Brad’s family car) and we made our way to The Farm as it was euphemistically called by most locals. We were admitted at the gate after being frisked (I assumed for hacksaw blades), but later I would learn that there were no bars to see here, the inmates good behavior got them assigned here to farm rather than make license plates.
We all were nervous. Not only was the opposing team older by decades but they also had cheerleaders with pom-poms and there were at least 200 feisty fans (all dressed alike!) in the stands surrounding the whole field. Of course we had no visitors routing for us – but the guys gave each of us polite claps when we went to the plate.
The two umpires were prison guards and we hoped they weren’t in the clink for fraud. The visiting team batted first. Magoo got a walk which was greeted with a burst of catcalls and other comments not suitable for print here. This was intimidating as we had never played before more than two or three fans in the stands. I batted clean up and reluctantly walked to the plate after our next two hitters whiffed on 6 identical 128 mile per hour fast balls. I dug into the batter's box and then the catcher said, “Son I wouldn't try to get a hit if I were you, he murdered his mother to get in here.” The ump smiled. Psychological warfare is fair I guess.
Out on the mound Dizzy Smith’s stare burned into my brain. He had a unique triple dipping swirling wind up. Bam - strike one. Bam another strike into the glove. I didn't even see the ball leave his hand. Two pitches later I was out at first base after a weak dribbler. And so it went – oh how we the sanctimonious church mighty fell that night. The princes of the Church League got drubbed 33 to 1 ( we all knew that the run on a walk was just so we would come back again)
After the game we were escorted into the immense prison kitchen where we were treated to the largest chocolate chip cookies I had ever seen. And to fresh cold milk from the farm dairy. The coach of the Farmers, assured us that their win was a fluke. They would take it easy on us if we would promise to come back – we hemmed and hawed. He sweetened the pot – he offered us a dinner next time of grilled steaks and fresh corn on the cob from the field. We could not say no to this incentive and did return for two more games that summer. We got to know these guys well and all were gentlemen and lovers of the game, albeit a tad rough around the edges. We ended up winning one game because it rained in the fifth inning. To a man, they were all good sports. And appreciative that we kids would take time to play against them. I became a firm believer that the system was working for their renewal.
I learned that Dizzy had another 10 years and was indeed jailed for manslaughter and I was glad I didn’t get too many hits off of him. Some of the others would rejoin society sooner as their crimes were minor ones. We went back again until we “graduated” from our Sunday School class. Each year some of our opponent’s faces changed. I hoped they became model citizens, their farm team days were over.
I never really found out if this was true - but I know one thing for certain - the cookies were outstanding.